What's the point of our society and "culture" anyway?, 11°

Okay, so it's a bit on the existential tip, but roll with me: I watched two really thought provoking documentaries at the Reel Earth film festival over the weekend. One was about the Sea Shepherd and how the captain and crew went to disrupt brutal activities like whaling and the annual seal hunt in Canada. The other had to do with the ghastly effects of Agent Orange used in Vietnam 2 and 3 generations after the war.

Between the bleak images of thuggish Canadians stomping seal skulls and disfigured humanity (both not pretty), I had to think back to some rather banal discussions I've been subjected to about the likes of America's Next Top Model (and equally stupid things). I wonder how we've been convinced to care so much about things that don't matter, and why we suffer such a profound disconnect from things that really need our attention.

I was emotionally stirred, perhaps even a bit upset by what I saw in the films, but it made me want to do something, and made me feel so fortunate that at least in my own life, there is some solace in the little things-- food, shelter, health... I had a renewed sense of purpose and perspective.

Then later to flip on the TV for a cultural comparison and see all the usual distractions of the day..plastic surgeries for people with a slightly imperfect nose, the consumerist onslaught, plethora of crime dramas-- it just didn't seem right.

How many thousands of years of human development have lead us to this rather strange age we find ourselves in. Does it seem to anyone else like we've lost the plot as a species?

There's so much talk about saving "the planet" (like we don't live here or something), but really what we're talking about is saving ourselves.

But what are we saving exactly? What of our "culture" as a species actually has genuine value anymore? What progress have we really made? What is really the point of human existence in a world where selfishness, brutality, violence, and ignorance still reign so frequently?

For me, I find value in compassion, human relationships, personal responsibility, being able to enjoy clean air and relatively safe food, crafting something meaningful using the best of my skills, and pursuit of a higher purpose.

What about you?

6 replies

Lindis C. 199°

Blimey! What a big question, Chris! I will resist the temptation to remind you that the answer is 42, and try to think a bit deeper.

I seriously think we have been brainwashed into thinking that we are helpless in the face of the big issues. A lot of people seem to think the only thing they have control over in their life is whether they buy a 42" flat screen TV or a 55". We have been tricked into thinking we have "choices" by being faced with a huge range of (for example) antibacterial cleaners or skin-smoothing serums - and it doesn't seem to occur to people that there are MUCH more important choices they are making every day.

But don't despair. My optimism comes from knowing there is a sub-culture that, despite being bombarded with all the same messages as everyone else, continues to see past the brainwashing and can imagine a better world. And better still, these people take action to achieve their vision!

Just as long as we keep encouraging people to discuss the issues, get politically active, make informed choices, and communicate with others (through films or this website for example!) there is still optimism in the world.

So keep it up! You - and all of us - really can make a difference!

Written in August 2009

I think we are living in a time of enormous change and it's fascinating. The internet I think is progress in a world-changing, culture-shifting, revolutionary way. It is showing a few billion of us how interconnected we are, and spreading knowledge like never before, but we forget that it's really incredibly new technology (at least in its current people-friendly form).

Because so many of us have only been thinking about these tough questions for a few years, we overlook how quickly culture changes, probably because we've never had cause to think about it before. Looking back on the past gives me hope for the future. So, in terms of climate change, if we look at 2050 (41 years from now) as the 'end zone' where emissions have to be down 80-90%, I find it reassuring to look back at where the world was 41 years ago -- to get a sense of how much things could potentially change by 2050. I did some research on this last year, when it was 42 years (see Lindis, 42 IS the answer! Or at least, it was last year). Will post it in a separate blog entry as it's quite long.

As for America's Next Top Model, man, I NEED that sort of thing. if I only thought about heavy, hard issues all the time and didn't tune out for a couple hours a day, I'd end up seriously freakin' depressed and be no use to anyone. It's like medicine to me! But I guess that just proves the point that TV really is the opiate of the masses.

Written in September 2009

The blog isn't up on the 3 News site anymore, so I've tweaked it for 2009 and posted it on the Good website:
http://good.net.nz/blog/annabel-mcaleer/a-few-t...

Written in September 2009

Robert A. 40°

When I listen to music I think 'human kind' might be 'here for a reason' but then I look at all the disgusting things we can get up to, from mass murder to child molestation, and the mega cruelty to animals 'we' perform by the second.
We act no differently than cockroaches. But even if we were all Buddhist monks the very simple maths of 6.8 billion people fitting on this finite planet, without fossil fuels, and not damage the environment so badly that 'we' can not survive, is imposable. Just the simple act of feeding us all is now more than the current environment can naturally produce
Humans manufacture 2 times more nitrogen than Nature and that goes into food production and comes from natural gas. Clearly things can not go on, not using plastic bags isn't going to help;) a bit like taking a cup of water to the Victorian bush fires. Investing in Kiwi Saver will not help ether, but the green party seem to think so.
This one hour experiment is in it's 59th minute http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fPcgW6zPzg
As for the internet, I predict it will die soon enough, as it is very very dependent on oil, and a functioning economy, no jobs, no money, no internet, and no oil, no coal, no electricity, no internet.
The more I know about humans the more I love my dog.

Written in September 2009

Cheryl K. 15°

I can totally understand how you feel. Sometimes I look at what's going on in the world, the terrible things being done by people to other people, animals, the environment...and well, although it sounds horrible, I sometimes think to myself that humanity doesn't deserve to be saved. It seems that everybody is too consumed in their lifestyle to care about anything important anymore. Even the end of the world would be less important than having a new pair of shoes, or a new TV or getting a higher paying job.

But then again, not everybody is like that. There are still things worth saving in the world. And don't forget the multitude of animal and plant life co-inhabiting this planet with us...so we're not just trying to save ourselves. There are other people who also strive for a higher purpose and have compassion and actually care and are trying to do their bit.

I can't blame people at large for doing the things they do, because they have been moulded by society to think that way. Civilization in the last thousand years has gone through what I'll call the "Technological Age". Science and technology has advanced in leaps and bounds...but unfortunately, wisdom, morality and compassion didn't follow in it's wake.

But don't give up; at the end of the day, each person can only do the best he/she can, and no matter what the outcome is, if you've done your best, that's all you can do. All big changes have to start somewhere.

Written in September 2009

Thanks for all your replies... it's been most interesting journey through the comments... good to know that people out there can see both sides of the coin. I guess I resonate with you Annabel about the TV (or other) escapism for people working in this area so we do not get utterly depressed... but as you noted, it is so easy for that to become utterly the ONLY thing people focus on.

I guess here is another thing philosophically that I'm grappling with: what is the balance between doing good out there in the world and still trying to get something for yourself at the end of the day? How much warrants a noble personal sacrifice, and how much is being a needless martyr? As for my case, I've resolved to likely not have kids, not interested in pets, gave up the car, minimise consumption, reuse materials, eat organic... but travel (and from NZ -- planes) is definitely my Achilles heel. Where do you draw that line in life of experiences you are willing to give up, vs. what you view as necessity? How do you make that call?

Written in September 2009

Pledge to do these related actions

Grow more fish, 17°

Enhancing poorer seabed ecologies acts to promote the growth and health of fish populations.

Support your local farmers' market, 368°

Locally-grown produce can reduce the amount of energy required to grow and transport the food ...

Swap something with someone, 61°

I swapped some thermal lining to make curtains the other day for a skirt made ...

Follow this related project

Eco-My-Flat

Christchurch, New Zealand

Featured project

View now ›

Sponsors

Featured organisation

View now ›